My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. The show premiered in January 2016, and since then, it has become one of the most popular true crime podcasts on the internet. The format of the show is simple: each episode features the hosts discussing a different murder or true crime story, ranging from famous serial killers to obscure, little-known cases. Read more.

My Favorite Murder Podcast

What sets My Favorite Murder apart from other true crime podcasts is its unique blend of humor and empathy. Kilgariff and Hardstark are both comedians, and they use their wit and humor to lighten the mood while discussing often gruesome and disturbing subject matter. However, they also take a compassionate approach to the victims and their families, highlighting the human element of each story.

Listen:

The podcast has spawned a large and dedicated fan base, known as the “Murderinos,” who connect with each other online and at live events. In addition to the podcast, Kilgariff and Hardstark have released a best-selling book, launched a network of other podcasts, and hosted a television series based on the podcast.

My Favorite Murder has been praised for its unique approach to the true crime genre, blending humor and compassion to create a one-of-a-kind listening experience. The hosts’ chemistry and relatable personalities have also contributed to the show’s massive success. The podcast continues to grow in popularity, and it shows no signs of slowing down anytime soon.

Why it is so popular?

My Favorite Murder is popular for its unique blend of true crime and comedy. The hosts, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, are both comedians who share a fascination with true crime stories. They have a relatable and conversational style of storytelling that keeps listeners engaged and interested in the cases they discuss. In addition to their witty banter, they also prioritize sensitivity and respect towards the victims and their families. The podcast has created a community of listeners who appreciate their approach to discussing true crime, and many feel a sense of camaraderie with the hosts.

The most popular episodes

The My Favorite Murder podcast has released over 300 episodes, with many of them becoming popular among its listeners. Some of the most popular episodes include:

  1. Episode 118: “Golden State Killer Caught”. The breaking news that the infamous Golden State Killer. A serial rapist and murderer from the 1970s and 80s. He had finally been identified and arrested after decades of eluding authorities.
  2. Episode 43: “My Firstest Murder”. The hosts earliest memories of becoming interested in true crime. It includs their personal experiences with murder and crime in their hometowns.
  3. Episode 13: “Serial Killers of the ’70s”. Karen and Georgia discuss some of the most notorious serial killers of the 1970s. Such as Ted Bundy and the Son of Sam.
  4. Episode 131: “Live at the Civic Theatre in San Diego”. Stories of some of the most infamous murders that have taken place in San Diego. Along with some spooky local ghost stories.
  5. Episode 167: “Live at the Wilbur Theatre in Boston”. The hosts discussing some of the most infamous crimes that have taken place in Boston. Such as the Boston Strangler and the Gardner Museum heist.

The criticisms

In 2019, it was reported that the hosts received backlash from fans for their comments on the murder of University of Utah student Mackenzie Lueck. The hosts had made jokes about the case, which some listeners felt were insensitive and inappropriate. The hosts later apologized for their remarks.

Additionally, there have been concerns raised about the hosts profiting from the true crime genre, with some accusing them of “exploiting” the stories of murder victims for entertainment purposes. However, the hosts have defended their show as a way to raise awareness about important issues, such as mental health and personal safety.

Categorized in: